公正

公正

[美] 迈克尔·桑德尔

intermediate10 chapters · 22 levels

曾经我觉得所有东西都是可以量化的,甚至感情,然而我又倾向于推崇选择的自由,比如在不影响他人利益的前提之下,我认为人可以随意处置自己。作者在书中批判了功利主义的行为,他认为这使公正和权利变成一种算计,而非原则。将所有的人类等量齐观,实际上却忽视了它们之间质的区别。而自由选择则没法解决类似代孕母亲之类的问题,人们也许会丧失判断的能力,那在这样情况下做出的选择,是否算数?作者宣扬的共同善其实不太能够说服...

1

The Moral Dilemmas of Daily Life

An exploration of how we define justice through real-world scenarios like price gouging and bailouts, introducing the three main schools of thought: welfare, freedom, and virtue.

The Price of Disaster

Three Maps for Justice

2

The Utilitarian Calculus

Investigating Jeremy Bentham's 'greatest happiness' principle and John Stuart Mill's attempt to humanize it by respecting individual liberty.

The Calculus of Pleasure

Putting a Price Tag on Life

Higher vs. Lower Pleasures

3

The Sovereign Self: Libertarianism

Focuses on the idea that justice means respecting self-ownership and the right to choose, challenging the ethics of wealth redistribution.

The Minimal State

The Moral Case Against Taxes

4

Markets and Moral Limits

Applying market logic to sensitive areas like military service and reproduction to see if everything should be for sale.

Soldiers for Hire

Commercializing Creation

5

Kant's Logic of Duty

A deep dive into Immanuel Kant's demanding philosophy, where morality is found in the motive and the categorical imperative.

Why Intentions Matter

The Categorical Imperative

Freedom as Autonomy

6

The Fair Society: John Rawls

Examining the social contract through the 'Veil of Ignorance' to determine how we would distribute resources if we didn't know our own identity.

The Veil of Ignorance

Winning the Genetic Lottery

7

The Affirmative Action Debate

Using college admissions to explore whether justice is about compensating for the past or promoting a diverse future.

Correction or Diversity?

Detaching Justice from Merit

8

Who Deserves What? Aristotle

Revisiting the Greek roots of justice, where rights are linked to the 'telos' (purpose) of social practices and the cultivation of virtue.

Flutes for the Best Players

Politics as the Pursuit of Virtue

9

Loyalty and Responsibility

Do we have special obligations to our family and country that we didn't choose? Sandel looks at the limits of individualism.

Ancestral Sins

The Dilemma of Loyalty

10

Justice and the Common Good

The conclusion argues that we cannot remain neutral on moral and religious questions and must engage with the 'good life' to achieve justice.

The Myth of Neutrality

A New Politics of the Common Good

Start reading with AI

Interactive Socratic dialogue, level by level

Get Started